DMACC NJCAA All-Americans (since 2000)
Baseball
- Chris Richardson- 2nd Team (2004)
- Tyler Robbins-1st Team (2008)
- Jake Astor-1st Team (2008), 1st Team (2009), National Player of the Year (2009)
- Patrick Cooper- 1st Team (2009)
- Joel Hutter- 1st Team (2010)
- Scott Schebler- 2nd Team (2010)
- Hibraim Cordova- 3rd Team (2011)
- Alec Crawford- 1st Team (2012)
- Alex Lashomb- 3rd Team (2012)
- Edwin Medina- 1st Team (2013)
- Roman Collins- 1st Team (2014), National Player of the Year (2014)
- Anthony Mrosla- 3rd Team (2015)
- Jake Adams- 1st Team (2016)
- Austin Murr- 3rd Team (2019)
- Chance Key- 3rd Team (2024)
Men's Basketball
- Shelton Colwell- Honorable Mention (2000-01), 1st Team (2001-02)
- Ian Young- 2nd Team (2002-03)
- Frashon McGee- Honorable Mention (2003-04)
- Al Stewart- Honorable Mention (2004-05)
- Grant Burns- 2nd Team (2007-08)
- Scott Windom- 3rd Team (2008-09)
- Nate Mason- 3rd Team (2011-12)
- Brandon Nazione- 2nd Team (2013-14)
- Aarias Austin- 2nd Team (2014-15)
- Tray Buchanan- 3rd Team (2018-19)
- Willie Guy- 1st Team (2020-21)
- Jadan Graves- 1st Team (2021-22)
- Angelo Winkel- 1st Team (2023-24)
Softball
- Jaden Ott- 1st Team (2013)
- Kalli Wells- 2nd Team (2013)
- Mackenzie Alstott- 3rd Team (2013)
- Kaitlin Briley 2nd Team (2014)
- Brittney Roby- 1st Team (2015), 2nd Team (2016)
- Sydney Weldon- 1st Team (2015)
- Madi Parrott- 2nd Team (2015)
- April Brown- 3rd Team (2015)
- Kenzi Ihle- 1st Team (2016)
- Claire Dudek- 2nd Team (2016), 1st Team (2017)
- Kenzie Sutton- 3rd Team (2016)
- Molly Jacobsen- 1st Team (2017), 1st Team (2018)
- Bailey Richards- 1st Team (2018)
- Mia Ruther- 1st Team (2018), 1st Team (2019)
- Morgan Neely- 1st Team (2018)
- Josie Swafford- 1st Team (2019)
- Sophie Maras- 1st Team (2021)
- Abby Husak- 2nd Team (2021)
- Kendal Clark- 1st Team (2022)
- Jada Collins- 1st Team (2022)
- Emma Dighton- 2nd Team (2022)
- Abby Husak- 3rd Team (2022)
- Sydney Kennedy- 1st Team (2023)
- Courtney Donahue- 1st Team (2024)
Volleyball
- Iulia Porumbescu- 1st Team (2002)
- Allison Hyland- 2nd Team (2003)
- Danielle Pegram- 2nd Team (2004)
- Ashley Bayer- 1st Team (2006)
- Liz Schreck- Honorable Mention (2006)
- Shelby DeNeice- 1st Team (2007)
- Kayla Knobbe- Honorable Mention (2007)
- Bobbi Bayer- 1st Team (2008), 1st Team (2009)
- Katie Heuer- Honorable Mention (2008)
- Justin Young- Honorable Mention (2009)
- Shella Menezes- 1st Team (2013)
- Taylor Case- 1st Team (2014), 1st Team (2015)
- Shelby Schouten- 2nd Team (2014)
- Moriah Johnson- 2nd Team (2016)
- Amber Disaver- Honorable Mention (2019)
- Emma Flathers- 2nd Team (2023)
Women's Basketball
- Jenny Harle- 3rd Team (2003-04)
- Ashley Freerksen- 3rd Team (2004-05)
- Jocelyn Anderson- 2nd Team (2005-06), 2nd Team (2006-2007)
- Kaitlyn Wood- 3rd Team (2010-11)
- Carlee Schuhmacher- 1st Team (2012-13), 1st Team (2013-14)
- London Vais- 1st Team (2015-16)
- Grace Flanagan- 2nd Team (2020-21)
Women's Golf
- Jaime Bellingham- Honorable Mention (2016-17)
Men's Golf
- Noah Hartman- Honorable Mention (2018-19)
- Dylan Ellis- 1st Team (2020-21)
- Tyler Sansgaard- 2nd Team (2020-21), 2nd Team (2021-22)
- Drew Teeter- 1st Team (2023-24)
- Calvin McNeeley- 1st Team (2023-24)
- Spencer Clatt- 2nd Team (2023-24)
Women's Cross Country
- Natalia Segura- Honorable Mention (2022-23)
- Kayden Spencer- Honorable Mention (2023-24)
- Kayden Spencer- Honorable Mention (2024-25)
- Grace Collins- Honorable Mention (2024-25)
Men's Cross Country
- Caden Brown- 2nd Team (2024-25)